I don't think any one is claiming that design is bad and designers should never have "got involved", your parent comment is saying that we've gone too far.
Today, lots of websites use full-width images and videos on their landing pages, make multiple requests for all sorts of assets and use all sorts of tracking and analytics code. More and more often I find myself closing a tab in frustration because the page is taking too long to load. Blogs, e-commerce sites, this is getting quite common.
I interpreted your parent comment as a call for minimalism, nothing more.
> The jarring "Oh the CSS hasn't loaded" moment is precisely what he wants you to experience.
But I honestly don't experience that moment. I see some text and I start reading it. You're over-thinking, IMO.
That you didn't notice the lack of CSS is precisely why you need to see this from the point of view of a non-technical person. If my mother-in-law saw this page, she would probably call me screaming that her computer had broke or she had been hacked.
Today, lots of websites use full-width images and videos on their landing pages, make multiple requests for all sorts of assets and use all sorts of tracking and analytics code. More and more often I find myself closing a tab in frustration because the page is taking too long to load. Blogs, e-commerce sites, this is getting quite common.
I interpreted your parent comment as a call for minimalism, nothing more.
> The jarring "Oh the CSS hasn't loaded" moment is precisely what he wants you to experience.
But I honestly don't experience that moment. I see some text and I start reading it. You're over-thinking, IMO.