Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submitlogin

We might also consider that the LLMs will take traffic away from original sources, much like Google Search showing the relevant passages that answer your question. It's not always about outputting the exact passage, though this point may be tangential to the post & case at hand.

My primary usage of LLMs fit this pattern. Use Bard for simple programming questions, typically something I would have previously searched for via docs/reference/SO for. Now I don't have to filter the results or skim the pages for the right section, it's just given to me, and I can ask/make follow up questions or corrections. This here is what makes them much better than vanilla search, the ability to iterate and refine.



I think in some ways LLMs have shown people want simple answers to their questions when they pose it to a search engine.

Stack Overflow was good because it had answers (one chosen as right) and a little bit of discussion about why and how and other considerations.

Much of the web is verbose to an extreme to get the search engines to rank it highly. People don't want that, they just want answers.


This is exactly right, and hopefully the LLMs can get better at adding in the

> discussion about why and how and other considerations

If(when) they knew when/how to ask better follow up questions, that will take it to the next level


> We might also consider that the LLMs will take traffic away from original sources, much like Google Search showing the relevant passages that answer your question.

That said, Google has motivation not to over do it though as millions of websites are part of their ad network. If people stop visiting the sites, they lose money too.


Paradigms have changed, chat will be a primary modal for search in time. This is why Bing and Goog are both finding ways to get ads into our chat experiences. We might be forced away from ad dollars being the primary way to pay for the internet. With data privacy, ideally content based ad placement over individual targeting (think magazine style ads), the move to paid access to sites or content... there are trends that may combine to break the current foundations.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: