> What do you mean by smart? A well organized moderately smart person is more productive to a company than a disorganized genius.
Maybe Yes, maybe No, depends entirely on the job function they're in, the assumed style and heaviness of management and how much communication (if any), let alone oversight, they are obligated to have with their peers and subordinates. I have seen people who rarely emerged from their room/cubicle yet consistently produced brilliant code; versus people who looked and sounded amazing in meetings yet didn't deliver. There is definitely such a thing as too much communication, btw, which Elon Musk points out regularly. Have you ever been inside a company that talked and meeting'ed and memo'ed itself to death? I have. Sometimes you need a crew that simply quickly agree a sensible plan, shut up and build the dang thing lightning-fast before the cash runs out and the lights get turned off.
There are organization styles that thrive on lone wolves and ICs and know how to manage them hands-off, and ones that thrive on big-company style corporate 'team players'. There's a place for everyone.
'smart' IME is far less a measure of IQ/EQ and more 'robustly adaptive to whatever arbitrary management structure you try to force on them'.
Maybe Yes, maybe No, depends entirely on the job function they're in, the assumed style and heaviness of management and how much communication (if any), let alone oversight, they are obligated to have with their peers and subordinates. I have seen people who rarely emerged from their room/cubicle yet consistently produced brilliant code; versus people who looked and sounded amazing in meetings yet didn't deliver. There is definitely such a thing as too much communication, btw, which Elon Musk points out regularly. Have you ever been inside a company that talked and meeting'ed and memo'ed itself to death? I have. Sometimes you need a crew that simply quickly agree a sensible plan, shut up and build the dang thing lightning-fast before the cash runs out and the lights get turned off.
There are organization styles that thrive on lone wolves and ICs and know how to manage them hands-off, and ones that thrive on big-company style corporate 'team players'. There's a place for everyone.
'smart' IME is far less a measure of IQ/EQ and more 'robustly adaptive to whatever arbitrary management structure you try to force on them'.