Hacker Newsnew | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | more Multicomp's commentslogin

A cheesy Roller Coaster Tycoon clone in a browser, one-shotted from an AI? Amazing capabilities. The entire "low code drag n drop" market like YoYoGames Game Maker and RPG Maker should be ready to pack it in soon if this keeps improving in this way.


I forget if it was Samsung or Sony, but somewhere along the way on my internet journey, someone claimed, without evidence, and thus I have none either, that the incentive structure for having prestige jobs at large technology companies was always in hardware design and software was seen as easier and more low class.

So since nobody will get any promotions for running good software, they are not incentivized to run good software, and therefore they do just enough to get by?


This is historically the reason software engineering in Japan has lagged and there's such a talent shortage (leading companies like mine to hire mostly foreign software engineers). I've heard it's changing, but it'll take a long time to catch up.


When I was working for Microsoft China, many of our foreign engineers were Korean and Japanese, who were in China for the higher paychecks.


Yes this is true and it might possibly be true for the rest of East Asia though I'm not sure. Software is considered intangible and thus low value that anyone can do, whereas hardware is a real "thing" that you can hold in your hands, and is therefore more prestigious. Well, this way of thinking has made things into the current state.


This was and partly is the attitude you can find in german non-software businesses where software is gaining more and more influenxe. For example car manufacturing.


> this instance is a case of abusing the law to reward friends of the administration

I don't think this is an interesting take for anyone, but this reminds me of how the nineteenth century American political system was called the spoils system, and this seems like a twenty first century echo of that.


That is a completely apt comparison, especially in light of a recent SCOTUS decisions that allow the president to appoint loyalists to positions previously supposed to be non-partisan.


AI component libraries in your site make your web app even more easily consumed and subsumed by AI chat clients.

This not only kills pages, but it kills the concept of a browser where the user agent is a human, rather than making your pages be designed where the user agent is an AI agent.

That doesn't make me happy to experience because I'm guessing that after a generation or so, web designers will not only do mobile first designs with stupid amounts of white space and not taking advantage of the desktops greater screen real estate and precise mouse movements, but AI first websites will get so popular that browsing sites manually will look like trying to use a text only browser in the JavaScript world.

Easy for me to do a depressing take, but hopefully the bitter lesson of AI will help this particular projected future not come to pass because the AI will get smart enough that it will embed a browser right there in line and just render the window for the user, or it will otherwise gets good enough at screen scraping and UI automation that it can just use an existing browser, just like a human, the sites won't be dumbed down even further for AI consumption.


to add to that, it kills the concept of whether the host is human (and not just another soulless megacorp harvesting your data in their walled garden)

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=46969751 remark that they're taking down their self-hosted projects citing costs associated with AI scraping.

at best we have walled garden content; and when those are scraped (either by the host or by more sophisticated bots) those walled gardens will hopefully rot under an inability to drive advertisement revenue.

I agree, I think we're at the edge of a paradigmatic shift away from humans navigating TCP-IP itself. What that looks like, I don't know, but given trends (like dynamic pricing, human-futures marketing, surveillance, and consolidation of computing under mega-companies) I can imagine: local beacons screaming AI advertisement components across a geospatial sneakernet. Auditorium-based ticketed podcasting and AR/VR/meatspace events. Thoughtful hackers reminiscing of better times simulating them in web-assembly driven first-person POV "sites" and a rolling set of encryption keys for read-access (just send them BTC)

without an ecosystem for humans to contribute meaningfully to a feedback loop that allows for free group assembly around like interests, monetary growth for hosts and other participants, and some degree of presence / searchability / permanence, the current text-only web page paradigm is doomed.


> AI first websites will get so popular that browsing sites manually will look like trying to use a text only browser in the JavaScript world.

That might be great for accessibility, though.


I am of course unqualified to provide useful commentary on it, but I find this concept to be new and interesting, so I will be watching this page carefully.

My use case is less so trying to hook this up to be some sort of business workflow ClawdBot alternative, but rather to see if this can be an eventually consistent engine that lets me update state over various documents across the time dimension.

could I use it to simulate some tabletop characters and their locations over time?

that would perhaps let me remove some bookkeeping how to see where a given NPC would be on a given day after so many days pass between game sessions. Which lets me do game world steps without having to manually do them per character.


That's a very interesting use case you brought to the table! I've also dreamt about having an agent as my co-host running the sessions. It's a great PoC idea we might look into soon.


I built out Nexus 2 years ago and have run Jfrog 4+ years ago, and now am back at the Artifact Repo choosing process again. I'm going to try to get away with AWS ECR for containerized artifacts to defer purchasing a proper versioned artifact repo, but I will be keeping a close eye on this one, I respect the work and design that went into this. I couldn't have done it better myself!


thanks for the recommendation, I've put a hold on it for my library now.

This article reminds me of another book [1] called Holacracy where how a business is run is systematized according to other pre-defined principles. David Allen, a productivity trainer, used it at his own company for several years before eventually moving away from it because the ongoing overhead to keep its system up was too much.

I wonder if this system will end up like that as well. I love the idea, but I think humans operate at a squishier level than our computers do, there's a risk of 'massive bureaucratic dehumanization and inflexible processes' and the Iron Law of Organizations that make such efforts as that book and this article fraught with peril. Taylorism has its limits.

But hey, if this works, I'll be excited to see more businesses adopting better practices and less painful fumbling around trying to do practices in an organic or unplanned way.

[1] https://www.holacracy.org/blog/dac-ceo-reflects-on-holacracy...


I'm so amazed to find out just how close we are to the start trek voice computer.

I used to use Dragon Dictation to draft my first novel, had to learn a 'language' to tell the rudimentary engine how to recognize my speech.

And then I discovered [1] and have been using it for some basic speech recognition, amazed at what a local model can do.

But it can't transcribe any text until I finish recording a file, and then it starts work, so very slow batches in terms of feedback latency cycles.

And now you've posted this cool solution which streams audio chunks to a model in infinite small pieces, amazing, just amazing.

Now if only I can figure out how to contribute to Handy or similar to do that Speech To Text in a streaming mode, STT locally will be a solved problem for me.

[1] https://github.com/cjpais/Handy



Happy to answer questions about this (or work with people on further optimizing the open source inference code here). NVIDIA has more inference tooling coming, but it's also fun to hack on the PyTorch/etc stuff they've released so far.


And here I was wondering if someone was plotting their tabletop game scenario plots or creative writing plots using claude to do some bookkeeping sonI was the creatorncould focus on brainstorming in a writers room of 1+1.

Oh well, still an interestign article that shows statistics can be posed in such a way to say anything about anything if you squint them.


I agree with this article, Id never seen the priority vs impact chart before.

One thinf I would add is that a given incident can have differing internal vs external impact, which can drive up its cumulative impact.


Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: